69 Must-Know Hotel Statistics and Travel Trends in Shelter Island (NY), United States for 2025

Hotel Availability and Types in Shelter Island (NY)

Number of Hotels

• There are 5 hotels in Shelter Island (NY).

Distribution by Star Rating

• Shelter Island (NY) has 1 hotels with a 2-star rating, accounting for 20.0% of all hotels.
• Shelter Island (NY) has 1 hotels with a 3-star rating, accounting for 20.0% of all hotels.
• Shelter Island (NY) has 3 hotels with a 4-star rating, accounting for 60.0% of all hotels.

Hotel Pricing Trends in Shelter Island (NY)

Average Prices Over Time

• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) is $427 per night.

Average Price by Star Rating

• The average price of a 2-star hotel in Shelter Island (NY) is $447 per night.
• The average price of a 3-star hotel in Shelter Island (NY) is $592 per night.
• The average price of a 4-star hotel in Shelter Island (NY) is $378 per night.

Hotel Price Distribution

• There are 4 hotels in Shelter Island (NY) priced in the $200-$500 range, accounting for 80.0% of all hotels.
• There are 1 hotels in Shelter Island (NY) priced in the $500-$1000 range, accounting for 20.0% of all hotels.

Best Month to Visit by Price

• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in January is $301.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in February is $333.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in March is $283.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in April is $288.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in May is $368.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in June is $466.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in July is $728.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in August is $757.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in September is $513.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in October is $450.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in November is $425.
• The average price of a hotel in Shelter Island (NY) in December is $342.

Hotel Ratings and Reviews in Shelter Island (NY)

Number of Reviews

• We've collected 149 reviews for hotels in Shelter Island (NY).

Review Distribution by Traveler Type

• There are 5 reviews from business travelers in Shelter Island (NY), accounting for 3.4% of all reviews.
• There are 70 reviews from couples in Shelter Island (NY), accounting for 47.0% of all reviews.
• There are 28 reviews from families in Shelter Island (NY), accounting for 18.8% of all reviews.
• There are 8 reviews from friends in Shelter Island (NY), accounting for 5.4% of all reviews.
• There are 6 reviews from group travelers in Shelter Island (NY), accounting for 4.0% of all reviews.
• There are 13 reviews from solo travelers in Shelter Island (NY), accounting for 8.7% of all reviews.
• There are 19 reviews from travelers with an unknown type in Shelter Island (NY), accounting for 12.8% of all reviews.

Average Hotel Ratings Over Time

• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in 2024 was 7.16, based on 41 reviews.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in 2023 was 9.44, based on 43 reviews.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in 2022 was 7.95, based on 45 reviews.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in 2021 was 8.21, based on 14 reviews.

Average Ratings by Star Rating

• The average rating for 2-star hotels in Shelter Island (NY) is 6.43.
• The average rating for 3-star hotels in Shelter Island (NY) is 8.58.
• The average rating for 4-star hotels in Shelter Island (NY) is 8.63.

Average Ratings by Traveler Type

• The average rating for business travelers in Shelter Island (NY) is 6.17.
• The average rating for couples in Shelter Island (NY) is 7.61.
• The average rating for families in Shelter Island (NY) is 6.99.
• The average rating for friends in Shelter Island (NY) is 9.78.
• The average rating for group travelers in Shelter Island (NY) is 9.33.
• The average rating for solo travelers in Shelter Island (NY) is 9.05.
• The average rating for travelers with an unknown type in Shelter Island (NY) is 8.24.

Best Months to Visit by Ratings

• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in January is 10.00.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in February is 7.33.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in March is 10.00.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in April is 7.92.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in May is 8.25.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in June is 8.68.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in July is 8.23.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in August is 7.60.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in September is 6.58.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in October is 8.79.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in November is 9.32.
• The average rating for hotels in Shelter Island (NY) in December is 8.00.

Seasons in Shelter Island (NY)

The seasons in Shelter Island (NY) are determined by the percentage of reviews for each month.